Top-of-foot pain: tight laces, tendons or a stress fracture?

Short answer

Common causes of pain on top of the foot include tight shoes irritating the tendons that lift your toes (extensor tendinitis), a stress fracture from doing too much too soon, sprains, arthritis and gout. Rest, raising the foot, ice and looser, low-heeled shoes help most cases. Pain that's worse with every step, swelling over a bone, or pain after increasing your mileage needs an exam for a stress fracture.

Common causes

CauseClues
Extensor tendinitisAche along the top of the foot; tight shoes or laces make it worse (Cleveland Clinic).
Stress fractureGradual pain worse with weight-bearing, swelling and tenderness over one spot on a bone; often after training more (AAOS).
Sprain or strainAfter a twist or injury.
Arthritis or goutJoint pain; gout comes on suddenly, red and very tender.

Home care

The NHS recommends resting and raising the foot, ice for up to 20 minutes every 2–3 hours, comfortable low-heeled shoes, and pain relief. As a common-sense measure, loosen your laces over the sore area or skip the eyelet that presses on it.

Cleveland Clinic says extensor tendinitis takes a few weeks to a few months; AAOS says most stress fractures take 6–8 weeks to heal.

See a doctor or podiatrist if:
  • You can't walk, the foot looks deformed, or you heard a snap (go to urgent care).
  • There's swelling and pinpoint tenderness over a bone, especially after more activity (possible stress fracture).
  • You have fever, redness and heat.
  • Pain lasts more than 2 weeks, or you have diabetes (NHS).

Sources

  1. NHS: Pain in the top of the foot
  2. Cleveland Clinic: Extensor Tendinitis
  3. AAOS OrthoInfo: Stress Fractures of the Foot and Ankle